← Council

Farnsfield parish council review finds broken finances and a village at odds with itself

Photo: Illustration by ChattyLion/Ai

This is your last free story. Register free for 5 a month.

Register free

An unofficial governance report records nine clerks in three years, a £32,000 accounting error and claims of a private “caucus” now being examined by the district council’s monitoring officer.

A review of Farnsfield Parish Council has found that the authority’s financial systems are close to non-existent, that relations between councillors, clerks and residents have broken down, and that allegations of an informal group steering council policy are under investigation by Newark and Sherwood District Council.

The report was written by William Bradshaw with the council’s new clerk, Binal Sawjan, and its contents were first reported by the Newark Advertiser on 26 October. It is not a statutory audit or a formal inquiry. Mr Bradshaw drew it from a series of private conversations with individual councillors and residents, intended to describe the state of affairs in the village rather than to rule on disputed facts. Even so, its findings on money and governance are stark for a council that sets a precept and manages public assets on behalf of the village’s residents.

The most concrete concerns are financial. The review describes the council’s financial controls as “incredibly poor, almost non-existent”. It cites a councillor who paid £350 to have the village tennis courts power-washed without the council’s approval, and reports that the draft accounts for 2023 contained an error of £32,000. Large sums of public money, according to the report, cannot be formally accounted for. It also points to evidence that some councillors have disregarded decisions recorded in the minutes.

Instability in the council’s administration appears to sit behind much of this. Since the 2023 local elections, Farnsfield has had nine clerks, a figure the report calls worrying and disturbing. The clerk also acts as the council’s responsible financial officer, the person legally answerable for its accounts, so the turnover has left the council without continuity in the role that should have caught errors of the kind the review describes. Six councillors have been co-opted onto the council since 2023 rather than elected. Earlier this year the post was being advertised by a locum clerk, Peter Leppard, as a 25-hour-a-week role based partly at the Farnsfield Village Centre on New Hill.

The report’s account of the village’s politics is harder to verify and more contentious. It describes a “complete lack of trust” between councillors and some residents, a number of whom are former councillors who have taken an increasingly active interest in parish affairs. Residents told Mr Bradshaw they were concerned about a lack of transparency and about arrogance on the council’s part. Councillors, for their part, reported aggressive and threatening behaviour from members of the public, both in meetings and online. The review also records complaints about social media conduct, bullying and the deletion of important information.

Its most pointed passage concerns what it calls persistent reports of a councillor-led “caucus” of serving and former councillors and members of the public, known locally as “Plough Sunday”, which is said to meet regularly. Some councillors have also behaved in ways that gave an impression of favouring certain village clubs, the report says, which has fuelled persistent allegations of corruption.

One councillor who attends the gatherings told the reviewer that council business is never discussed and that the group is a long-standing circle of friends. Another councillor who disputed the allegations said they could be slanderous. The report itself makes no finding either way. It notes that the district council’s monitoring officer, who handles complaints about councillors’ conduct, is investigating, but predicts the inquiry is unlikely to establish more than one person’s account set against another’s speculation.

Mr Bradshaw is explicit that he is not adjudicating. Whether each claim is true is not the point, he writes; there is enough evidence that the behaviour across all sides is toxic and wasteful of time and energy. Every person he spoke to, he adds, named improving the village as their priority, and he calls for civil conduct among all parties to begin immediately, regardless of past grievances.

Councillors agreed to publish the report after being given a right of reply.

It proposes four areas for the next stage of the review: a village plan, clearly defined roles and relationships between councillors, clerk and public, proper financial systems, and a review of how the council manages information. None of these has yet been formally adopted, and no timetable has been published. The outcome of the monitoring officer’s investigation into the “Plough Sunday” allegations is still awaited.

Stories like this cost money to report.

Brit7 News is independent and Newark-owned. Back us for £1 for your first month.

Support local journalism

Know more about this story? Contact the newsroom

Have your say

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *