X

Home Office strips approval from motorway speed cameras after second fault found

National Highways is ending its enforcement contract with US supplier Verra Mobility, as an independent review sets out how a timing error led to 2,650 wrongful camera activations.

Variable speed cameras on England’s smart motorways will no longer be used to prosecute drivers. The government told Parliament on Tuesday that the Home Office had revoked the system’s type approval after testing found a second possible fault. The new fault comes from the same 2019 upgrade that led to thousands of motorists being wrongly caught speeding.

In a written statement, Justin Madders, the roads minister, said National Highways would end its contract with Verra Mobility, the American company that supplies the devices, to use the cameras for enforcement. He said the company was “considering all further commercial and legal options that may be appropriate.” National Highways, which is owned by the government, bought the system because it held Home Office type approval. That status makes the cameras’ readings easier to admit as evidence of fact in court. Without it, the data loses that standing.

The new problem concerns how the cameras may switch on in certain conditions. National Highways’ modelling puts the chance of those conditions arising at no more than 0.1 per cent, and the government says there is no real-world evidence that enforcement has been affected. The Home Office still concluded that the issues could not be fixed to its satisfaction within a reasonable time. Ministers, Mr Madders wrote, would not accept “any scenario where there is a hypothetical risk some drivers could be prosecuted incorrectly.” He told the BBC: “If we’re going to prosecute people, we need to be confident the system is working as it should.”

According to the BBC, the affected sites include all variable speed cameras on smart motorways, a section of the A14 between Huntingdon and Cambridge, and the A1 approach junction to the A14. The BBC reported that the latest fault may have allowed drivers to escape fines. Neither the government nor National Highways has confirmed any such case.

The first fault came to light last year. Some cameras responded to changes on the signs with a delay of around ten seconds. As a result, drivers could be recorded against a lower limit after a higher one was already showing overhead. In December 2025 Simon Lightwood, then the transport minister, told MPs that there had been about six million activations on the affected cameras, meaning fewer than 0.1 per cent were wrong. Police were asked to refund fines and remove penalty points. National Highways had already told its supplier on 17 October 2025 to stop sending variable speed data to police forces, and the investigation was later extended back to 2019.

The Westall Review, published alongside Tuesday’s statement, gives the fullest account yet of how this happened. Tracy Westall, a non-executive director at the Department for Transport, found that 154 HADECS3X cameras in 22 police force areas caused the 2,650 wrongful activations between 2021 and 2025. The system did not recognise rapid changes to the limits shown on variable signs. Coverage of the report says Avon and Somerset Constabulary alerted National Highways to a possible problem with an M5 offence on 25 January 2025. Dashcam footage from a member of the public exposed the mismatch, and Ms Westall writes that the fault might otherwise have stayed hidden. National Highways did not inform the Department for Transport until 10 September.

Her recommendations fall under seven themes, including corporate governance, crisis handling, legal advice and procurement. The government and National Highways have accepted all of them, and the department says it will hold the company to account through its existing sponsorship arrangements. Ms Westall concluded that the discovery of the second fault left her recommendations unchanged.

Edmund King, president of the AA, called it a “damning review” and said it identified ten missed opportunities to prevent or deal with the problem. He estimated that around a million speeding events might go unpunished and urged that a new provider be brought in quickly. The government has published no comparable figure.

Until then, enforcement will rely on other means. National Highways put extra traffic officer patrols in place at the affected sites on Tuesday. It is also using existing CCTV and number-plate recognition cameras, as well as the radar that detects stopped vehicles on stretches without a hard shoulder. The government says its monitoring shows drivers are obeying limits at “the usual high levels.” The overhead signs will stay in use to manage traffic flow. “If you break the law you should expect to be subject to enforcement action,” Mr Madders wrote.

The statement gives no timetable for replacing the cameras and does not say which system might succeed them. Verra Mobility had not responded to request for comment. National Highways has not said whether it will seek damages from the company.

Categories: TRAFFIC
admin: